Giving an Onion

 

A key scene, just after the middle of The Brothers Karamazov: Alyosha is stricken with complicated grief at the death of Elder Zosima, whose teaching of extreme humility and joy in life has sunk deep into his soul, and yet he is wavering, bereft. A friend, Rakitin, dubiously suggests getting drunk, and he agrees! Rakitin then suggests visiting Grushenka, a young woman of about the same age as Alyosha (i.e. 20), who has said she would like to seduce—”destroy”—Alyosha. So they go. She has been sitting on Alyosha’s knees for several pages when she learns from Rakitin of Zosima’s death. Instantly she realizes the effect this has had on Alyosha, and she leaps from his lap to the sofa, crossing herself. “Merciful Lord, oh, what am I doing, sitting on his knees at a time like this?” Then we read: “Alyosha gave her a long look of astonishment and something in his face seemed to light up.”
 
And he says to Rakitin: “I don’t want to feel any rancour towards you, and so please try to be more kind. I have lost a treasure [in the death of Zosima] such as you have never possessed. . . . You would do better to look over here, at her: did you see how she spared me? I came here in order to find an evil soul . . . and instead I found a sincere sister.” And to her Alyosha says, “You have just resurrected my soul.”
 
It was a small act, beautiful in its spontaneity and the hidden goodness it revealed: her quick grasp of Alyosha’s grief and her “instant” leap from his knees to the sofa. Grushenka tells Rakitin, “though I may be wicked, I’ve still given my onion.”
— 
When she was a girl she had heard an old fable of a wicked woman who died and was in the lake of fire because she had never done a good deed. Her guardian angel, though, remembered that she once gave an onion to a beggar. So, with God’s permission, the angel holds the onion to the woman and says if she can hang onto it he will pull her up out of the lake of fire. She does, and she is rising from the lake, when suddenly all the other lost souls around her grab onto her, wanting to escape with her, and they are now all rising from the lake. But in her wickedness she kicks at them and says no: “The onion’s mine, not yours.” And at that moment the onion breaks and they all fall back into the lake of fire.
— 
Grushenka says that, with Alyosha just then, she had given her onion. She confesses that “it is the only good deed I’ve ever done.” But Alyosha sees the balance of guilt and innocence differently. He called her a sister. In a sense, they have each given an onion to the other: she in her mercy for him in the midst of his grief, and he when he sees her as a sister. Each has touched the other’s heart to the core. They have given their “onions,” small merciful deeds of kindness. But unlike the woman in the fable, their little onions have vast and yet undisclosed consequences for the rest of their lives.
—
Out & About. Sunday, Nov. 22, I am to preach at St. John’s Church in Corsicana, Tex., at the 9:30 Eucharist. Then on Advent Sunday, Nov. 29, I am to preach at St. Matthew’s Cathedral in Dallas, at 9 and 11:15 a.m. 
— 
Good Books & Good Talk: The final session on The Brothers Karamazov is coming. We will discuss the dramatic conclusion of this magnificent novel of Dostoyevsky's. To-wit: 
Book 10, Alyosha, the schoolboys, their sick comrade, their love and cruelty to each other;
Book 11, Ivan's conversations with Smerdyakov, glimpses of absolute cruelty without love;
Book 12, Dmitri's trial, a great miscarriage of justice;
And the Epilogue, which is, for many, the most moving part of the entire book. Jump ahead and read it even if you haven't the time to read all that comes before.
In Dallas, on Sun. Nov. 29 at 5pm, in the Great Hall of St. Matthew’s Cathedral.
You are welcome even if you missed earlier sessions, and even if you have not yet read the part being discussed. Dostoyevsky is beautiful and deep and rich, wherever and whenever you pick him up.
— 
I’ve read many translations of The Brothers Karamazov over the years, and each one has its virtues. Above I quote from David McDuff’s translation in the Penguin Classics edition.
 

The Rev. Canon Victor Lee Austin. Ph.D., is the Theologian-in-Residence for the diocese and is the author of several books including, "Friendship: The Heart of Being Human" and "A Post-Covid Catechesis.: