Good Deeds aka "Onions"
In a Russian folk tale, a wicked person has died and gone to the fiery lake with all the others of her sort. Her guardian angel, though, knows she once did a good deed. It was a very small deed: she gave an onion to a beggar. The angel takes that good deed down to her and tells her if she can hang onto the onion, she will be pulled up out of the lake of fire.
This story is told in Book Seven, right at the middle, of The Brothers Karamazov. It raises the question of how good deeds can bring about the salvation of a human being. What “salvifically” is going on in the doing of something good for someone else? I think of three things:
First, a good deed requires putting someone besides ourselves at the center of one of our actions. A great deal of evil in the world is done because we unthinkingly put ourselves at the center of the whole world. We see the world through our eyes, which is to say, from our own perspective. We are the center of all we see. It is hard to escape this self-centeredness, but in doing something good we precisely do escape it.
Second, a good dead involves self-forgetfulness, even if for only a moment. This means that if our purpose is to deceive people by doing something good for them, what we do is not a “good deed.” If I give attention to someone because I want them to trust me enough to give me access, eventually, to their bank account—the attention I give is not loving attention but calculated. In the old Russian folk tale, the woman spontaneously gave an onion to a beggar without thinking of any return she might get from it—and, of course, not thinking that someday her good deed might be a means of her salvation.
Third, a good deed is an instance of the second great commandment, which is to love your neighbor as yourself. A good deed involves seeing a similarity between yourself and the person for whom the deed is done. This is sometimes called “solidarity”: our recognition that we are connected with other people. In truth, we are in solidarity with all human beings, but hardly ever are we aware of that. We can learn this solidarity through concrete instances of doing good deeds. We can build up habits that then shape our minds and hearts more broadly.
It is a mystery why Jesus says the second commandment about neighbor-love is “like unto” the first. But surely part of that mystery is that through concrete acts of love we may start to see into a particular, deep mystery of God: that it was out of his love for the world that he sent his son Jesus. God, who loves not only self-centered me but also self-centered Jose and Josephine, is someone we start to love as we start to move out of our self-centered, self-attentive, self-protective lives.
Good deeds are not salvific by themselves. In the folk tale, the woman remains self-centered, thinks only of herself, and has no sense of her solidarity with the other sinners in the lake. As she is being pulled up, the others want to escape with her and cling onto her. She kicks them away, saying, No, this is my onion! And at that point the onion breaks and all of them remain unsaved.
Nonetheless, good deeds fit with faith in God and a growing sense of the necessity of losing our own self-centeredness. InThe Brothers Karamazov, there are many characters who describe themselves as the worst people in the world, but at the same time talk about having received an onion and perhaps also having given an onion. And it is those characters who are moved to tears and sorrow and joy—sometimes all at once—and for whom it is some onion, some good deed, that was the turning point in their story.
—
Out and About. This Sunday, Nov. 22, I am to preach at St. John’s Church in Corsicana, Tex., at the 9:30 Eucharist. Then on Advent Sunday, Nov. 29, I am to preach at St. Matthew’s Cathedral in Dallas, at 9 and 11:15 a.m.
—
Good Books & Good Talk: The final session on The Brothers Karamazov will soon be here: on Sun. Nov. 29 at 5pm, in the Great Hall of St. Matthew’s Cathedral, Dallas. We will cover the dramatic conclusion of this magnificent novel of Dostoyevsky’s. To-wit:
Book 10, Alyosha, the schoolboys, their sick comrade, their love and cruelty to each other;
Book 11, Ivan's conversations with Smerdyakov, glimpses of absolute cruelty without love;
Book 12, Dmitri's trial, a great miscarriage of justice;
And the Epilogue, which is, for many, the most moving part of the entire book. Jump ahead and read it even if you haven’t the time to read all that comes before.
You are welcome even if you missed earlier sessions, and even if you have not yet read the part being discussed.
—
Following up: A reader writes in appreciation of the idea of “Calvinist shampoo” (in my post on Being Young, a couple of weeks ago). He notes that we do have “Quaker oats” and thinks he once saw “Methodist oats.” This puts me in mind of “A Prairie Home Companion,” the radio show which had several fake sponsors, one of them being “Mournful Oatmeal,” which reminds you that you aren’t as bright or good as you might think. Its tagline was, “No matter where you go, there you are.”